Editors Note: This is the third in our series comparing various states as retirement destinations. Don’t miss the first, Florida vs. Arizona Retirement, or the second, Delaware vs. Maryland vs. Virginia vs. New Jersey. There are more “Dueling” comparisons listed at the end of this article. We welcome ideas for future ones.
Updated April 5, 2015 — Both North and South Carolina enjoy a favorable image among baby boomers; in fact the Carolinas are a red-hot retirement destination. As a retirement destination, both have become at least as desirable is Florida. In this comparison we will evaluate various factors for both states that affect retirement, letting you draw your own conclusions from the facts. As always, reader input is extremely important, so we encourage you to use the Comments section below. (Note: The first version of this article was originally published in 2010; this edition contains numerous updates and revisions. Because it goes way back to 2010, there are a LOT of comments which are worth reading. The latest comments are at the bottom.)
Population (Data from American Fact Finder-U.S. Census Bureau).
One obvious difference between the two states is the number of people. In 2013 North Carolina’s population was about double its southern neighbor’s (9,848,060 vs. 4,774,839). The over 65 population in South Carolina was 14.2%, in North Carolina it was slightly lower at 12.9% (the national percentage was 13.4%). Both states attract significant numbers of retirees from beyond their own borders, usually from the Northeast or Midwest.
Home Prices and the Economy
One reason why the Carolinas are popular for so many retirements is a lower cost of living. Both states have significantly lower home prices than the Zillow 2015 Home Value Index for the entire U.S. of $178,700. Using that same source, South Carolina’s median home value was $134,700, $12,000 lower than North Carolina’s ($146,700). Note that the Zillow estimates are low compared to those from the National Association of Realtors, which showed a U.S. median home price of $208,700 at the end of 2014.
Home prices in some North Carolina Metros bear out these differences: the Durham median home selling price at the end of 2014 was $205,200; in Charlotte it was $192,800, and in Raleigh it was $213,200 (per NAR). Meanwhile in South Carolina, the Greenville median was $166,000, Spartanburg was $130,900, but in pricier Charleston the median was $215,500.
The economies of both states are very similar. Manufacturing, services, and agriculture are important in both. The 2013 median HH income in North Carolina was $46,334, slightly higher than South Carolina’s $44,779. By comparison the national household income median was $50,046. South Carolina’s cost of living is the 21st lowest in the U.S. while North Carolina’s is very similar at 23rd. According to the Census Bureau both states had some of the highest unemployment rates in the nation in 2013 – 11.4% for South Carolina and 11.1% for North Carolina (people over 16 years of age).
There are no significant climate differences between these 2 states. The most northern parts of North Carolina will have slightly colder winters than the most southerly part of SC, but the difference will only be a few degrees. What differences there are mostly stem from the varying climates present within each as they go east to west – from beach to mountains. Here are a few representative temperatures for cities within these states:
City(State) Avg July High Avg Jan Low
Asheville (NC) 84 27 (West)
Charlotte(NC) 90 32 (Central)
Wilmington (NC) 90 36 (East)
Greenville (SC) 89 31 (West)
Columbia (SC) 95 36 (Central)
Charleston (SC) 89 42 (East)
Many retirees look to tax comparisons to help determine what they view as a retirement friendly state. Up until last year South Carolina would undoubtedly win that comparison – it had lower taxes in almost every category. However, beginning in 2014 comparing taxes between the two states is much harder, and the bottom line difference is probably not that great. According to the Tax Foundation, SC had the 41st highest tax burden in the nation in 2011, whereas NC’s was 17th. However due to the dramatic changes in NC’s tax structure in 2014, those figures are probably not valid after that date.
To make a few observations, we would start by saying that the individual characteristics of your tax situation have so many ramifications that you should have someone prepare a hypothetical tax statement for you to get the real picture. But here are some things to consider:
– SC has a much higher marginal tax rate, although it also has higher exemptions
– Neither state taxes Social Security
– The sales tax in NC is 1.25% lower than in SC
– Neither state has an inheritance or estate tax
– NC has higher property taxes as a % of home value. But it also has a nice “circuit breaker” program for people over 65
South Carolina has a (very high) maximum tax rate of 7% that begins at a quite low income of $14,400. South Carolina accepts the adjustments, exemptions and deductions allowed on your federal tax return. North Carolina’s income tax is much lower, as it was recently lowered to a flat 5.75%.
Social Security and Income Tax Exemptions for Seniors
Neither state taxes Social Security payments.
Although South Carolina has much higher tax rates, its high exemption levels are friendly to retirees. Each resident over 65 is entitled to an exemption of $15,000 ($30,000 for couples) in calculating income for state tax purposes, of which up to $10,000 each can be retirement income. For couples filing jointly when both are 65 or older you might not need to file a SC tax return unless your gross income is greater than the federal gross income filing requirement plus $30,000.
There is a $7500 exemption per person in NC. When North Carolina reduced its state income tax rates starting with 2014 some seniors’ deductions were eliminated. Social Security is still exempt, as is NC pension income under the Bailey Settlement. The somewhat confusing pension exemption rules are located on this NC Retiree Tax Guide.
The northern Carolina wins in the sales tax competition. In SC the sales tax is 6% and in NC it is 4.75%. Both states permit localities to add on to that tax.
Estate and Inheritance Taxes
There are no estate or inheritance taxes in South Carolina or North Carolina (NC repealed its estate tax in 2013).
SC residents pay one of the lowest property taxes as a % of home value (ranked 46th) in the country. NC is ranked 33rd. SC residents pay .57% of their home value, compared to .85% in North Carolina (figures from the Tax Foundation). Homeowners in SC over 65 can usually deduct $50,000 of valuation on their property taxes. In NC there is a property tax homestead exemption for people over 65 who meet certain income criteria, as well as a circuit breaker program for eligible people over 65 which limits property taxes to 4 or 5% of your income.
Note: Taxes are complicated and the laws change quickly. Consult state Department of Revenue Guides and/or your tax professional before making important decisions. This brief overview is not meant to give any advice.
Physical Environment and Diversity
As with population, North Carolina also has a much bigger geographical area – 54,000 square miles as compared to SC’s 32,000 miles. Both have a long coast line with beautiful beaches and/or waterfront on large bays. The Cape Hatteras region of NC is quite remarkable, as is Myrtle Beach and Hilton Head in SC. North Carolina has a larger and more pronounced western mountain area with four seasons and the Blue Ridge, Great Smoky, and Black Mountain ranges. The highest point in NC (and the eastern U.S.) is Mt. Mitchell at 6,684 ft.; Sassafras Mountain is SC’s highest peak at 3,560 ft.
Places to Live and Retirement Popularity
Both states have several important cities and numerous interesting mid-sized cities. Both states have college towns, such as Chapel Hill and Durham in NC and Clemson in South Carolina. Both Carolinas have a strong representation of towns on Topretirements’ list of 100 Best Retirement Towns: NC has 11 on that list and SC has 10. South Carolina has 4 cities in our top 20, whereas NC has only 2 (perennial #1 Asheville (NC) and #16 New Bern. South Carolina’s most popular places to retire include #4 Beaufort, #6 Charleston, #7 Myrtle Beach, #15 Bluffton, and #20 Summerville. Here is the full list of our most popular 100 best retirement towns.
Choice of Active Communities
North Carolina and South Carolina are both loaded with active adult communities. At Topretirements we count 178 communities in our North Carolina Directory of Active Communities and 154 in the South Carolina Directory of Active Communities. Whereas the active communities in NC are dispersed throughout the state in areas like Asheville, New Bern, Charlotte, and the Research Triangle area; South Carolina’s are clustered mostly along the coast, from Myrtle Beach to Charleston. In both states the choices are many and varied, with many of them relatively new.
The bottom line
North Carolina and South Carolina share numerous similarities in addition to a similar climate and topography. Indeed, many retirees say they are contemplating moving to the “Carolinas” for retirement, and don’t often specify one of the states.
Looking for differences, we could generalize and say North Carolina is a bit more diverse. It has more large cities to choose from, such as Charlotte or Winston-Salem. NC has taller mountains and more towns in mountainous areas, if that is what you are looking for. South Carolina might have the most interesting city, Charleston. NC is more diverse politically, with its cities, particularly those in the Research Triangle, tending to be progressive. Its rural areas are more conservative. North Carolina has made recent strides in getting to more a tax friendly par with South Carolina. South Carolina, which tends to be quite conservative, is probably less of a melting pot than its northern cousin, and more of a “southern” state. While North Carolina recently became much tax friendlier, many liberal leaning residents are not happy with the attendant cuts to social services, education, and other programs.
So which state is more popular? Regardless of which state wins the retirement sweepstakes, both are doing very well. A Del Webb study a few years ago found that the Carolinas had become a more popular retirement destination than Florida. At Topretirements our South Carolina retirement guide is visited slightly more than is our NC retirement guide (in fact they are the #2 and #3 most popular state guides after Florida). The differences between the Carolinas are subtle. Both contain some wonderful places to retire, if the mid-Atlantic region is the region where you would like to retire. Rather than take sides on the issue, we recommend that you visit cities and towns in both states and see if you can’t find the place of your dreams. Fortunately, the two states are contiguous- in a few trips you should be able to get a good idea of the places that could offer you a happy retirement experience.
Sources: In most cases we used www.tax-rates.com. as the source for tax information in this article, American Fact Finder for demographic information, and Zillow or the NAR for home pricing. Some additional tax burden figures are courtesy of the Tax Foundation.
For for further reading:
State Retirement Guides
Retirement 101 Mid-Atlantic States: MD, DE, VA, NJ
Florida Retirement 101
Dueling Carolinas: NC vs. SC
Dueling States: Arizona vs. Florida
California Retirement 101
Retirement in the Southwest: AZ, NM, and Utah
The Mountain States: CO, ID, MT, NV, UT, WY
The Pacific Northwest: Oregon vs. Washington
What state do you prefer? Let us know in the Comments section below. (Note: This article has been updated numerous times and has many interesting comments. To find the most recent ones scroll down and look by date).